CCactusSports Cards AZContact us
99.7% positive on eBay1.2K sold14-day returns

Peyton Manning Cards for Sale

We have 22 Peyton Manning cards in stock across 20 sets, priced $1.49 to $1,499.00, including 1 rookie card. 1 sale is on record here; the most recent was $120.00 on 2026-11-19.

22 Peyton Manning cards for sale (football), priced $1.49 to $1,499.00. Of those: 2 CGC-graded cards, 1 rookie card. Years run 1998 to 2005. Direct prices, offers welcome, ships from Arizona within 2 business days.

Shop all 22 Peyton Manning cards in the interactive store →

What we hold: Peyton Manning in stock

Sets on the shelf: 1999 Bowman's Best (2), 1998 Bowman (1), 1998 Topps Chrome (1), 1998 Upper Deck UD Choice StarQuest/RookQuest Blue (1), 1999 Bowman (1), 1999 Fleer Tradition (1) and 14 more.

Peyton Manning cards in stock by set

SetIn stockPrice
1999 Bowman's Best2$1.69 to $2.49
1998 Bowman1$500.00
1998 Topps Chrome1$1,499.00
1998 Upper Deck UD Choice StarQuest/RookQuest Blue1$3.64
1999 Bowman1$1.99
1999 Fleer Tradition1$2.00
1999 Topps1$1.99
1999 Topps Record Numbers1$1.99
2000 Bowman1$1.49
2000 Bowman Road to Success1$2.49
2000 Fleer SkyBox E-X Century Skylines1$3.99
2000 Topps Season Opener1$1.74
2000 Topps Season Opener - Coming Soon1$1.59
2001 Bowman1$1.69
2001 Topps1$1.50
2002 Bowman1$1.98
2003 Bowman Chrome1$1.99
2003 Topps Record Breakers1$1.99
2005 Topps Total1$1.69
2005 Topps Turn Back the Clock1$1.59

Most valuable Peyton Manning cards we have

  1. Peyton Manning 1998 Topps Chrome #165 CGC 10 $1,499.00
  2. Peyton Manning 1998 Bowman #1 CGC 10 RC $500.00
  3. Peyton Manning 2004 Upper Deck #UD-11 $3.99
  4. Peyton Manning 2000 Fleer SkyBox E-X Century Skylines #8 $3.99
  5. John Elway and Peyton Manning 1998 Upper Deck UD Choice StarQuest/RookQuest Blue #SR01 $3.64

What our Peyton Manning cards sold for

Straight answer, from our own shelf: the 22 Peyton Manning cards we hold are priced $1.49 to $1,499.00 today. That is what we ask, not an appraisal — grade, print run and the exact parallel move a card within that range.

What our Peyton Manning cards actually sold for

1 completed sale from this shop, $120.00. These are our own order records — no scraped comps, no estimates.

SoldCardPriceChannel
2026-11-19Peyton Manning 1998 Topps Draft Picks #360 CGC 9$120.00eBay
Peyton Manning 2003 Bowman Chrome #38Peyton Manning 2003 Bowman Chrome #38 $1.99Peyton Manning 1998 Topps Chrome #165 CGC 10Peyton Manning 1998 Topps Chrome #165 CGC 10 $1,499Peyton Manning 1998 Bowman #1 CGC 10 RCPeyton Manning 1998 Bowman #1 CGC 10 RC $500Peyton Manning 2004 Upper Deck #UD-11Peyton Manning 2004 Upper Deck #UD-11 $3.99Peyton Manning 2000 Fleer SkyBox E-X Century Skylines #8Peyton Manning 2000 Fleer SkyBox E-X Century Skylines #8 $3.99John Elway and Peyton Manning 1998 Upper Deck UD Choice StarQuest/RookQuest Blue #SR01John Elway and Peyton Manning 1998 Upper Deck UD Choice StarQuest/RookQuest Blue #SR01 $3.64Peyton Manning 1999 Bowman's Best #70Peyton Manning 1999 Bowman's Best #70 $2.49Jamal Lewis and Peyton Manning 2000 Bowman Road to Success #R2Jamal Lewis and Peyton Manning 2000 Bowman Road to Success #R2 $2.49Peyton Manning 1999 Fleer Tradition #2Peyton Manning 1999 Fleer Tradition #2 $2.00Peyton Manning 2003 Topps Record Breakers #RB22Peyton Manning 2003 Topps Record Breakers #RB22 $1.99Peyton Manning 1999 Bowman #70Peyton Manning 1999 Bowman #70 $1.99Peyton Manning 1999 Topps Record Numbers #RN9Peyton Manning 1999 Topps Record Numbers #RN9 $1.99Peyton Manning 1999 Topps #300Peyton Manning 1999 Topps #300 $1.99Peyton Manning 2002 Bowman #100Peyton Manning 2002 Bowman #100 $1.98Peyton Manning 2000 Topps Season Opener #117Peyton Manning 2000 Topps Season Opener #117 $1.74Peyton Manning 1999 Bowman's Best #95Peyton Manning 1999 Bowman's Best #95 $1.69Peyton Manning 2001 Bowman #67Peyton Manning 2001 Bowman #67 $1.69Peyton Manning 2005 Topps Total #338Peyton Manning 2005 Topps Total #338 $1.69Peyton Manning 2000 Topps Season Opener - Coming Soon #193Peyton Manning 2000 Topps Season Opener - Coming Soon #193 $1.59Peyton Manning 2005 Topps Turn Back the Clock #5Peyton Manning 2005 Topps Turn Back the Clock #5 $1.59Peyton Manning 2001 Topps #287Peyton Manning 2001 Topps #287 $1.50Peyton Manning 2000 Bowman #112Peyton Manning 2000 Bowman #112 $1.49

Peyton Manning cards by number

Every card in stock, in set and card-number order, so you can find a number you are missing.

Peyton Manning cards by number: set, card number, card and our price
Set#CardPrice
1998 Bowman1Peyton Manning 1998 Bowman #1 CGC 10 RC$500.00
1998 Topps Chrome165Peyton Manning 1998 Topps Chrome #165 CGC 10$1,499.00
1998 Upper Deck UD Choice StarQuest/RookQuest BlueSR01John Elway and Peyton Manning 1998 Upper Deck UD Choice StarQuest/RookQuest Blue #SR01$3.64
1999 Bowman70Peyton Manning 1999 Bowman #70$1.99
1999 Bowman's Best70Peyton Manning 1999 Bowman's Best #70$2.49
1999 Bowman's Best95Peyton Manning 1999 Bowman's Best #95$1.69
1999 Fleer Tradition2Peyton Manning 1999 Fleer Tradition #2$2.00
1999 Topps300Peyton Manning 1999 Topps #300$1.99
1999 Topps Record NumbersRN9Peyton Manning 1999 Topps Record Numbers #RN9$1.99
2000 Bowman112Peyton Manning 2000 Bowman #112$1.49
2000 Bowman Road to SuccessR2Jamal Lewis and Peyton Manning 2000 Bowman Road to Success #R2$2.49
2000 Fleer SkyBox E-X Century Skylines8Peyton Manning 2000 Fleer SkyBox E-X Century Skylines #8$3.99
2000 Topps Season Opener117Peyton Manning 2000 Topps Season Opener #117$1.74
2000 Topps Season Opener - Coming Soon193Peyton Manning 2000 Topps Season Opener - Coming Soon #193$1.59
2001 Bowman67Peyton Manning 2001 Bowman #67$1.69
2001 Topps287Peyton Manning 2001 Topps #287$1.50
2002 Bowman100Peyton Manning 2002 Bowman #100$1.98
2003 Bowman Chrome38Peyton Manning 2003 Bowman Chrome #38$1.99
2003 Topps Record BreakersRB22Peyton Manning 2003 Topps Record Breakers #RB22$1.99
2004 Upper DeckUD-11Peyton Manning 2004 Upper Deck #UD-11$3.99
2005 Topps Total338Peyton Manning 2005 Topps Total #338$1.69
2005 Topps Turn Back the Clock5Peyton Manning 2005 Topps Turn Back the Clock #5$1.59

Peyton Manning appears in these sets

Related players