Returns

Last updated October 5, 2026

Buy with confidence — if a card isn't what you expected, we'll make it right.

14-day returns

Return shipping

If we made the mistake (wrong card, condition not as described, or a card that is not authentic), the return label is on us. Otherwise the buyer covers return shipping — we recommend tracked shipping, since the card is your responsibility until it's back in our hands.

Not returnable

Authenticity

Every card we sell is guaranteed authentic. If a card, raw or graded, is shown not to be genuine, email us within 30 days of delivery: we refund the full price, including shipping, within 7 days of the returned card reaching us, the same as any return. A grade is the grading company's opinion, not ours. Full wording is in our Terms of Service, section 6 (Condition and grading).

Something arrive damaged?

Email photos of the card and packaging within 48 hours of delivery and we'll sort it out — every shipment is tracked. Tracked & insured orders (the default for orders over $20; free at $50 or more) are covered for loss in the mail up to $100, and coverage above that can be purchased; economy envelopes are tracked but not insured (see Shipping).